donate blood?

Forums General Melanoma Community donate blood?

  • This topic has 33 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 13 years ago by POW.
  • Post
    JC
    Participant

      can Stage I people donate blood?

      can Stage I people donate blood?

    Viewing 17 reply threads
    • Replies
        Harry in Fair Oaks
        Participant

          No – because a small number of people diagnosed Stage I have melanoma in their blood.  Why take the chance, however small, of transmitting melanoma?

          Best wishes,

          Harry

          Harry in Fair Oaks
          Participant

            No – because a small number of people diagnosed Stage I have melanoma in their blood.  Why take the chance, however small, of transmitting melanoma?

            Best wishes,

            Harry

            Harry in Fair Oaks
            Participant

              No – because a small number of people diagnosed Stage I have melanoma in their blood.  Why take the chance, however small, of transmitting melanoma?

              Best wishes,

              Harry

              Janner
              Participant

                Officially, after a period of time, it is allowed for most stages to donate blood.  The blood guidelines have changed.  However, I personally agree with Harry, why take any chances?  I am stage I for over 20 years now and my last primary was over 10 years ago.  Technically, I can give blood now.  But I won't.

                Janner
                Participant

                  Officially, after a period of time, it is allowed for most stages to donate blood.  The blood guidelines have changed.  However, I personally agree with Harry, why take any chances?  I am stage I for over 20 years now and my last primary was over 10 years ago.  Technically, I can give blood now.  But I won't.

                  Janner
                  Participant

                    Officially, after a period of time, it is allowed for most stages to donate blood.  The blood guidelines have changed.  However, I personally agree with Harry, why take any chances?  I am stage I for over 20 years now and my last primary was over 10 years ago.  Technically, I can give blood now.  But I won't.

                    Fen
                    Participant

                      Absolutely not.  Why risk affecting someone else's health.

                      Fen
                      Participant

                        Absolutely not.  Why risk affecting someone else's health.

                        Fen
                        Participant

                          Absolutely not.  Why risk affecting someone else's health.

                          JC
                          Participant

                            it's an ironic dichotomy; there's enough risk to the health of others to not donate blood…….but yet there isn't enough risk to the person's own health to do any kind of adjuvant therapy for Stage I……. or, is there?

                            JC
                            Participant

                              it's an ironic dichotomy; there's enough risk to the health of others to not donate blood…….but yet there isn't enough risk to the person's own health to do any kind of adjuvant therapy for Stage I……. or, is there?

                                Janner
                                Participant

                                  The fact that they allow the donation of blood for stage I means that no one in the blood bank world believes there is a risk for blood transfered melanoma for stage I.  I can't remember the waiting period, but it is a couple of years, I believe.  I have actually never read anything that indicated melanoma was transmitted by blood donation to a recipient.  However, there have been a few cases of early stage people who donated organs.  The organ recipients there ended up with melanoma.  Those recipients have to have their immune system suppresed which leave them open to any cells lying around.  I think the opinion around here is safe rather than sorry. 

                                  As for adjuvant therapy, there isn't effective adjuvant therapy for stage III.  Maybe if there was, it might be used for higher risk individuals.  However, stage I isn't high risk in any sense of the word.  The thing you may be forgetting is that organ and blood donor recipients are (or may be) immune suppressed.  That changes the dynamics some especially when it comes to organ donors.

                                  Janner
                                  Participant

                                    The fact that they allow the donation of blood for stage I means that no one in the blood bank world believes there is a risk for blood transfered melanoma for stage I.  I can't remember the waiting period, but it is a couple of years, I believe.  I have actually never read anything that indicated melanoma was transmitted by blood donation to a recipient.  However, there have been a few cases of early stage people who donated organs.  The organ recipients there ended up with melanoma.  Those recipients have to have their immune system suppresed which leave them open to any cells lying around.  I think the opinion around here is safe rather than sorry. 

                                    As for adjuvant therapy, there isn't effective adjuvant therapy for stage III.  Maybe if there was, it might be used for higher risk individuals.  However, stage I isn't high risk in any sense of the word.  The thing you may be forgetting is that organ and blood donor recipients are (or may be) immune suppressed.  That changes the dynamics some especially when it comes to organ donors.

                                    Janner
                                    Participant

                                      The fact that they allow the donation of blood for stage I means that no one in the blood bank world believes there is a risk for blood transfered melanoma for stage I.  I can't remember the waiting period, but it is a couple of years, I believe.  I have actually never read anything that indicated melanoma was transmitted by blood donation to a recipient.  However, there have been a few cases of early stage people who donated organs.  The organ recipients there ended up with melanoma.  Those recipients have to have their immune system suppresed which leave them open to any cells lying around.  I think the opinion around here is safe rather than sorry. 

                                      As for adjuvant therapy, there isn't effective adjuvant therapy for stage III.  Maybe if there was, it might be used for higher risk individuals.  However, stage I isn't high risk in any sense of the word.  The thing you may be forgetting is that organ and blood donor recipients are (or may be) immune suppressed.  That changes the dynamics some especially when it comes to organ donors.

                                    JC
                                    Participant

                                      it's an ironic dichotomy; there's enough risk to the health of others to not donate blood…….but yet there isn't enough risk to the person's own health to do any kind of adjuvant therapy for Stage I……. or, is there?

                                      JC
                                      Participant

                                        so if pre-melanoma diagnosis, i signed my driver's license to be an organ donor. . . then subsequently was diagnosed with Stage I melanoma, how does the state know I shouldn't be an organ donor any longer (should the situation arise)?

                                        JC
                                        Participant

                                          so if pre-melanoma diagnosis, i signed my driver's license to be an organ donor. . . then subsequently was diagnosed with Stage I melanoma, how does the state know I shouldn't be an organ donor any longer (should the situation arise)?

                                            POW
                                            Participant

                                              There are a whole host of diseases and conditions that can be unintentionally transmitted by blood transfusions, particularly when the recipient is immunosuppressed (on steroids, for example). There is always a risk when getting a transfusion. If you are concerned about accidentally transmitting melanoma (or anything else for that matter) I'm sure there is a way your state's motor vehicle department can send you a new license with the organ donor label removed.  

                                              POW
                                              Participant

                                                There are a whole host of diseases and conditions that can be unintentionally transmitted by blood transfusions, particularly when the recipient is immunosuppressed (on steroids, for example). There is always a risk when getting a transfusion. If you are concerned about accidentally transmitting melanoma (or anything else for that matter) I'm sure there is a way your state's motor vehicle department can send you a new license with the organ donor label removed.  

                                                POW
                                                Participant

                                                  There are a whole host of diseases and conditions that can be unintentionally transmitted by blood transfusions, particularly when the recipient is immunosuppressed (on steroids, for example). There is always a risk when getting a transfusion. If you are concerned about accidentally transmitting melanoma (or anything else for that matter) I'm sure there is a way your state's motor vehicle department can send you a new license with the organ donor label removed.  

                                                  Janner
                                                  Participant

                                                    Even if your license states you are a donor, the family is contacted before anything along those lines happen.  Make sure your family knows.  My drivers license used to say that too and I just attached a sticky note on the back stating "research donation or cornea donation only". 

                                                    Janner
                                                    Participant

                                                      Even if your license states you are a donor, the family is contacted before anything along those lines happen.  Make sure your family knows.  My drivers license used to say that too and I just attached a sticky note on the back stating "research donation or cornea donation only". 

                                                      lou2
                                                      Participant

                                                        I had my state remove my donation status from my drivers license, for another reason, and they did it.  So, just call them and find out how.

                                                        lou2
                                                        Participant

                                                          I had my state remove my donation status from my drivers license, for another reason, and they did it.  So, just call them and find out how.

                                                          lou2
                                                          Participant

                                                            I had my state remove my donation status from my drivers license, for another reason, and they did it.  So, just call them and find out how.

                                                            Janner
                                                            Participant

                                                              Even if your license states you are a donor, the family is contacted before anything along those lines happen.  Make sure your family knows.  My drivers license used to say that too and I just attached a sticky note on the back stating "research donation or cornea donation only". 

                                                            JC
                                                            Participant

                                                              so if pre-melanoma diagnosis, i signed my driver's license to be an organ donor. . . then subsequently was diagnosed with Stage I melanoma, how does the state know I shouldn't be an organ donor any longer (should the situation arise)?

                                                              JC
                                                              Participant

                                                                LifeSource says:

                                                                You may be temporarily ineligible to donate if you …

                                                                • Have the flu, a sore throat or fever.

                                                                • Are taking antibiotics for an infection..

                                                                • Have had heart problems.

                                                                • Received a blood transfusion in the past 12 months.

                                                                • Have been recently vaccinated (time of deferral varies). Flu shots do not disqualify you from donating.

                                                                • Have had a history of cancer (other than skin cancer).

                                                                JC
                                                                Participant

                                                                  LifeSource says:

                                                                  You may be temporarily ineligible to donate if you …

                                                                  • Have the flu, a sore throat or fever.

                                                                  • Are taking antibiotics for an infection..

                                                                  • Have had heart problems.

                                                                  • Received a blood transfusion in the past 12 months.

                                                                  • Have been recently vaccinated (time of deferral varies). Flu shots do not disqualify you from donating.

                                                                  • Have had a history of cancer (other than skin cancer).

                                                                    POW
                                                                    Participant

                                                                      This is confusing. LifeSource says you may be "temporarily ineligible" if you have a history of cancer (except skin caner).

                                                                      Does that mean that if you have skin cancer you can go ahead and donate (i.e., the "temporarily ineligible" does not apply to you)? Or does it mean that if you have skin cancer you are not temporarily ineligible but PERMANENTLY ineligible? Piss-poor writing, if you ask me. 

                                                                      POW
                                                                      Participant

                                                                        This is confusing. LifeSource says you may be "temporarily ineligible" if you have a history of cancer (except skin caner).

                                                                        Does that mean that if you have skin cancer you can go ahead and donate (i.e., the "temporarily ineligible" does not apply to you)? Or does it mean that if you have skin cancer you are not temporarily ineligible but PERMANENTLY ineligible? Piss-poor writing, if you ask me. 

                                                                        POW
                                                                        Participant

                                                                          This is confusing. LifeSource says you may be "temporarily ineligible" if you have a history of cancer (except skin caner).

                                                                          Does that mean that if you have skin cancer you can go ahead and donate (i.e., the "temporarily ineligible" does not apply to you)? Or does it mean that if you have skin cancer you are not temporarily ineligible but PERMANENTLY ineligible? Piss-poor writing, if you ask me. 

                                                                        JC
                                                                        Participant

                                                                          LifeSource says:

                                                                          You may be temporarily ineligible to donate if you …

                                                                          • Have the flu, a sore throat or fever.

                                                                          • Are taking antibiotics for an infection..

                                                                          • Have had heart problems.

                                                                          • Received a blood transfusion in the past 12 months.

                                                                          • Have been recently vaccinated (time of deferral varies). Flu shots do not disqualify you from donating.

                                                                          • Have had a history of cancer (other than skin cancer).

                                                                      Viewing 17 reply threads
                                                                      • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                                                      About the MRF Patient Forum

                                                                      The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                                                                      The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

                                                                      Popular Topics