Newly Diagnosed

Forums General Melanoma Community Newly Diagnosed

  • Post
    jwcollins
    Participant

      First time here since 2002 when I had melanoma removed from scalp. Was just diagnosed with metastatic in my right lung, one larger tumor (7CM) and a couple more half that size. I finished pallative radiation today and am waiting to hear if I qualify for a clinical trial in Seattle. If I don't qualify, any advice? Surgery and chemo are not options I've been told. My oncologist is highly respected and I trust his advice but I thought I'd check here for other thoughts. Thanks! 

    Viewing 14 reply threads
    • Replies
        A
        Participant

          I am so sorry about your diagnosis and hope you will get some answers regarding treatment options here on the board.

          Why did it come back after so many years??? What was the depth of your primary in 2002?
           

          A
          Participant

            I am so sorry about your diagnosis and hope you will get some answers regarding treatment options here on the board.

            Why did it come back after so many years??? What was the depth of your primary in 2002?
             

            A
            Participant

              I am so sorry about your diagnosis and hope you will get some answers regarding treatment options here on the board.

              Why did it come back after so many years??? What was the depth of your primary in 2002?
               

              DZnDef
              Participant

                Welcome to the group that no one really wants to join!  I'm sorry for your diagnosis but very glad that you found us.  There are some amazing people on this site including people with melanoma themselves or loved ones of melanoma warriors.  Many folks have done tons of research and I hope they will touch base with you shortly.  There are even some folks that check in here that are NED (No Evidence of Disease) twenty years after being diagnosed and after advancing to Stage IV.  I just want you to know that such a thing is possible.

                The first thing that I would suggest you do is to find yourself a melanoma specialist.  There have been many recent advancements in melanoma treatment that general oncologists might not be aware of or have much experience in.  I am not familiar with doctors in the Seattle area but I'm sure other folks will chime in with suggestions.  I would strongly encourge you to get multiple opinions and unless your tumor status is immediately life-threatening, wait to decide on your course of treatment until you have met with several recommended oncologists.  I met with three myself and received three different treatment recommendations. It is important that you are comfortable with your doctor and your doctor's approach.

                Best of luck and health to you!

                Maggie

                DZnDef
                Participant

                  Welcome to the group that no one really wants to join!  I'm sorry for your diagnosis but very glad that you found us.  There are some amazing people on this site including people with melanoma themselves or loved ones of melanoma warriors.  Many folks have done tons of research and I hope they will touch base with you shortly.  There are even some folks that check in here that are NED (No Evidence of Disease) twenty years after being diagnosed and after advancing to Stage IV.  I just want you to know that such a thing is possible.

                  The first thing that I would suggest you do is to find yourself a melanoma specialist.  There have been many recent advancements in melanoma treatment that general oncologists might not be aware of or have much experience in.  I am not familiar with doctors in the Seattle area but I'm sure other folks will chime in with suggestions.  I would strongly encourge you to get multiple opinions and unless your tumor status is immediately life-threatening, wait to decide on your course of treatment until you have met with several recommended oncologists.  I met with three myself and received three different treatment recommendations. It is important that you are comfortable with your doctor and your doctor's approach.

                  Best of luck and health to you!

                  Maggie

                  DZnDef
                  Participant

                    Welcome to the group that no one really wants to join!  I'm sorry for your diagnosis but very glad that you found us.  There are some amazing people on this site including people with melanoma themselves or loved ones of melanoma warriors.  Many folks have done tons of research and I hope they will touch base with you shortly.  There are even some folks that check in here that are NED (No Evidence of Disease) twenty years after being diagnosed and after advancing to Stage IV.  I just want you to know that such a thing is possible.

                    The first thing that I would suggest you do is to find yourself a melanoma specialist.  There have been many recent advancements in melanoma treatment that general oncologists might not be aware of or have much experience in.  I am not familiar with doctors in the Seattle area but I'm sure other folks will chime in with suggestions.  I would strongly encourge you to get multiple opinions and unless your tumor status is immediately life-threatening, wait to decide on your course of treatment until you have met with several recommended oncologists.  I met with three myself and received three different treatment recommendations. It is important that you are comfortable with your doctor and your doctor's approach.

                    Best of luck and health to you!

                    Maggie

                    Bubbles
                    Participant

                      Sorry that you have had to join us once again.  My first recommendation is, no matter how much you like and think of your oncologist, you need a melanoma specialist!!!  The difference that makes is tremendous!  Things have changed a lot since your previous diagnosis.  Ipi (Yervoy) is a first line, FDA approved immunotherapy available to you.  BRAF testing of your tumor (possibly via bonch???) might be important to you as well since there are many BRAF inhibitors, often incombination with MEK inhibitors, that might be very effective for you if you are positive for the BRAF mutation.  Nivolumab (Opdivo) and Keytruda…both are anti-PD1 products (another type of immunotherapy)…are also FDA approved now, though they have been approved as second line therapy after one has progressed on ipi and the BRAF inhibitors (if your tumor is BRAF positive).  There are also numerous clinical trials that hold promise.  Check out:  https://clinicaltrials.gov/

                      Put "Stage IV melanoma" in the search bar and you will see many options.  Two that I think are particularly interesting are:  https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02009384?term=stage+IV+melanoma&rank=21  and  https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02073123?term=stage+IV+melanoma&rank=18

                      The first trial gives a med to decrease T-reg levels before administering ipi….something that a lot of researchers think holds great promise and that a trial I particepated in gave credence to, in that those with lower T-reg levels before being given Nivolumab did better than those with higher levels at the start.

                      The second trial combines ipi with an IDO inhibitor.  Just another way to try to get better responses from ipi.

                      There are many, many more options and combos…this is just a brief pass.  Please ask questions of the knowledgeable folks here when you need.  Wishing you my best.  Celeste

                      Bubbles
                      Participant

                        Sorry that you have had to join us once again.  My first recommendation is, no matter how much you like and think of your oncologist, you need a melanoma specialist!!!  The difference that makes is tremendous!  Things have changed a lot since your previous diagnosis.  Ipi (Yervoy) is a first line, FDA approved immunotherapy available to you.  BRAF testing of your tumor (possibly via bonch???) might be important to you as well since there are many BRAF inhibitors, often incombination with MEK inhibitors, that might be very effective for you if you are positive for the BRAF mutation.  Nivolumab (Opdivo) and Keytruda…both are anti-PD1 products (another type of immunotherapy)…are also FDA approved now, though they have been approved as second line therapy after one has progressed on ipi and the BRAF inhibitors (if your tumor is BRAF positive).  There are also numerous clinical trials that hold promise.  Check out:  https://clinicaltrials.gov/

                        Put "Stage IV melanoma" in the search bar and you will see many options.  Two that I think are particularly interesting are:  https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02009384?term=stage+IV+melanoma&rank=21  and  https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02073123?term=stage+IV+melanoma&rank=18

                        The first trial gives a med to decrease T-reg levels before administering ipi….something that a lot of researchers think holds great promise and that a trial I particepated in gave credence to, in that those with lower T-reg levels before being given Nivolumab did better than those with higher levels at the start.

                        The second trial combines ipi with an IDO inhibitor.  Just another way to try to get better responses from ipi.

                        There are many, many more options and combos…this is just a brief pass.  Please ask questions of the knowledgeable folks here when you need.  Wishing you my best.  Celeste

                        Bubbles
                        Participant

                          Sorry that you have had to join us once again.  My first recommendation is, no matter how much you like and think of your oncologist, you need a melanoma specialist!!!  The difference that makes is tremendous!  Things have changed a lot since your previous diagnosis.  Ipi (Yervoy) is a first line, FDA approved immunotherapy available to you.  BRAF testing of your tumor (possibly via bonch???) might be important to you as well since there are many BRAF inhibitors, often incombination with MEK inhibitors, that might be very effective for you if you are positive for the BRAF mutation.  Nivolumab (Opdivo) and Keytruda…both are anti-PD1 products (another type of immunotherapy)…are also FDA approved now, though they have been approved as second line therapy after one has progressed on ipi and the BRAF inhibitors (if your tumor is BRAF positive).  There are also numerous clinical trials that hold promise.  Check out:  https://clinicaltrials.gov/

                          Put "Stage IV melanoma" in the search bar and you will see many options.  Two that I think are particularly interesting are:  https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02009384?term=stage+IV+melanoma&rank=21  and  https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02073123?term=stage+IV+melanoma&rank=18

                          The first trial gives a med to decrease T-reg levels before administering ipi….something that a lot of researchers think holds great promise and that a trial I particepated in gave credence to, in that those with lower T-reg levels before being given Nivolumab did better than those with higher levels at the start.

                          The second trial combines ipi with an IDO inhibitor.  Just another way to try to get better responses from ipi.

                          There are many, many more options and combos…this is just a brief pass.  Please ask questions of the knowledgeable folks here when you need.  Wishing you my best.  Celeste

                          kylez
                          Participant

                            What reason was given that chemo is not an option? If one splits hairs, most if not all current systemic therapies for melanoma are not "chemotherapy" per se, but rather either "targeted therapy" (e.g. Dabrafinib + Mekinist) or "immunotherapy" (e.g., Yervoy). Do you know if those types of systemic treatment were somehow ruled out? Was a BRAF DNA test done on a sample of one of the tumors? A lot of questions I know. If you haven't been given the answers, all the more reason to seek an oncologist who specializes in melanoma. If you're not sure how to find one, we can help here.

                            kylez
                            Participant

                              What reason was given that chemo is not an option? If one splits hairs, most if not all current systemic therapies for melanoma are not "chemotherapy" per se, but rather either "targeted therapy" (e.g. Dabrafinib + Mekinist) or "immunotherapy" (e.g., Yervoy). Do you know if those types of systemic treatment were somehow ruled out? Was a BRAF DNA test done on a sample of one of the tumors? A lot of questions I know. If you haven't been given the answers, all the more reason to seek an oncologist who specializes in melanoma. If you're not sure how to find one, we can help here.

                              kylez
                              Participant

                                What reason was given that chemo is not an option? If one splits hairs, most if not all current systemic therapies for melanoma are not "chemotherapy" per se, but rather either "targeted therapy" (e.g. Dabrafinib + Mekinist) or "immunotherapy" (e.g., Yervoy). Do you know if those types of systemic treatment were somehow ruled out? Was a BRAF DNA test done on a sample of one of the tumors? A lot of questions I know. If you haven't been given the answers, all the more reason to seek an oncologist who specializes in melanoma. If you're not sure how to find one, we can help here.

                                JoshF
                                Participant

                                  Sorry you had to join us. I hate when I hear stories of melanoma returning after such a long stretch let alone a recurrence for anyone. I think Bubbles is spot on, there are options and I would find someone who "knows" the ins and outs of melanoma. I'm also curious as to why chemo wouldn't be an option? I definitely wouldn't say that's the immeadiate thing to look too with all other treatments available but strange your oncologist would rule it our period. Wishing you the best!

                                   

                                  Josh

                                    jwcollins
                                    Participant

                                      Thanks so much to all of you. We are seeing a specialist (team?) up at Seattle Cancer Care Alliance on Wednesday and hopefully will know much more. I know BRAF testing was done, but for now we are on standby until we meet with the team and ask all the questions and start to hear options. I'll need to research all you've provided above. I am thinking research and awareness may be my best path forward. As for why it stayed dorment so long, that is the head scratcher for everyone so far. But it does sound like a nasty little critter by nature so…Anyway I will update asap and thanks again all.

                                      jwcollins
                                      Participant

                                        Thanks so much to all of you. We are seeing a specialist (team?) up at Seattle Cancer Care Alliance on Wednesday and hopefully will know much more. I know BRAF testing was done, but for now we are on standby until we meet with the team and ask all the questions and start to hear options. I'll need to research all you've provided above. I am thinking research and awareness may be my best path forward. As for why it stayed dorment so long, that is the head scratcher for everyone so far. But it does sound like a nasty little critter by nature so…Anyway I will update asap and thanks again all.

                                        _Paul_
                                        Participant

                                          I am in the care of the SCCA too and in my humble opinion they are a great organization. Shortly after my initial diagnosis, I was enrolled in a clinical trial at Johns Hopkins in Baltimore, another top notch facility for melanoms treatment. They were all very impressed by the folks at SCCA. You are in good hands!

                                          _Paul_
                                          Participant

                                            I am in the care of the SCCA too and in my humble opinion they are a great organization. Shortly after my initial diagnosis, I was enrolled in a clinical trial at Johns Hopkins in Baltimore, another top notch facility for melanoms treatment. They were all very impressed by the folks at SCCA. You are in good hands!

                                            jwcollins
                                            Participant

                                              I was not a candidate for any of the clinical trials at SCCA and decided against a study there combining yervoy and opdivo. I was negative for BRAF. So now we will just plug away with the yervoy alone and keep working on this till it's gone. Thanks all!

                                              jwcollins
                                              Participant

                                                I was not a candidate for any of the clinical trials at SCCA and decided against a study there combining yervoy and opdivo. I was negative for BRAF. So now we will just plug away with the yervoy alone and keep working on this till it's gone. Thanks all!

                                                jwcollins
                                                Participant

                                                  I was not a candidate for any of the clinical trials at SCCA and decided against a study there combining yervoy and opdivo. I was negative for BRAF. So now we will just plug away with the yervoy alone and keep working on this till it's gone. Thanks all!

                                                  _Paul_
                                                  Participant

                                                    I am in the care of the SCCA too and in my humble opinion they are a great organization. Shortly after my initial diagnosis, I was enrolled in a clinical trial at Johns Hopkins in Baltimore, another top notch facility for melanoms treatment. They were all very impressed by the folks at SCCA. You are in good hands!

                                                    jwcollins
                                                    Participant

                                                      Thanks so much to all of you. We are seeing a specialist (team?) up at Seattle Cancer Care Alliance on Wednesday and hopefully will know much more. I know BRAF testing was done, but for now we are on standby until we meet with the team and ask all the questions and start to hear options. I'll need to research all you've provided above. I am thinking research and awareness may be my best path forward. As for why it stayed dorment so long, that is the head scratcher for everyone so far. But it does sound like a nasty little critter by nature so…Anyway I will update asap and thanks again all.

                                                    JoshF
                                                    Participant

                                                      Sorry you had to join us. I hate when I hear stories of melanoma returning after such a long stretch let alone a recurrence for anyone. I think Bubbles is spot on, there are options and I would find someone who "knows" the ins and outs of melanoma. I'm also curious as to why chemo wouldn't be an option? I definitely wouldn't say that's the immeadiate thing to look too with all other treatments available but strange your oncologist would rule it our period. Wishing you the best!

                                                       

                                                      Josh

                                                      JoshF
                                                      Participant

                                                        Sorry you had to join us. I hate when I hear stories of melanoma returning after such a long stretch let alone a recurrence for anyone. I think Bubbles is spot on, there are options and I would find someone who "knows" the ins and outs of melanoma. I'm also curious as to why chemo wouldn't be an option? I definitely wouldn't say that's the immeadiate thing to look too with all other treatments available but strange your oncologist would rule it our period. Wishing you the best!

                                                         

                                                        Josh

                                                    Viewing 14 reply threads
                                                    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                                    About the MRF Patient Forum

                                                    The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                                                    The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

                                                    Popular Topics